Tuesday, May 22, 2007

Handling Criticism


Handling Criticism
Contents come from Rory Noland's The Heart of the Artist (chapter 5)

The dangers of defensiveness
  • It alienates us from others
  • Defensiveness keeps us from the truth
  • Defensiveness keeps us from being all we can be

Why it is difficult for artists to receive feedback
  • To be vulnerable is a price every performer pays.
  • Because art is such a personal thing, it’s difficult for us to separate ourselves from our work.
  • Another reason we feel vulnerable is because we are constantly being evaluated.
  • And it doesn’t help that critiquing the art is, more often than not, very subjective.

Responding to feedback

Be quick to listen
· Listen as a beloved child of God

Be slow to speak
· Our first response should not be a defensive one.
· Our first response should be to ask ourselves: Is any of this true?

Be discerning

Have a teachable spirit
· No matter what age you are, you always have something to learn

Learn how to fail graciously
· No one’s expecting perfection (except maybe us), so we don’t need to defend ourselves every time we fail.
· When we mess up, let’s swallow our pride, admit it, learn from it, and move on.

Giving feedback
  • Give your overall impression first
  • Try to say something positive
  • Acknowledge effort and hard work
  • Avoid hyperbole
  • Avoid negative comparisons

No comments: